Referee Form for:

28th Hawaii International Conference on Systems Sciences - January 1995
Minitrack on Hypermedia in Information Systems and Organizations

Reviewer Number   (from your referee letter): 
Manuscript Number (from your referee letter): HICSS95_
Manuscript Title: 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please select one of the six recommendation categories.  Then tick the
specific items in the section below that support your recommendation.  
Please include additional comments to the authors at appropriate items
and at the bottom of this form.  Due date: August 15, 1994   --- Thank you!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

RECOMMENDATION
--------------
Please select one recommendation (place an X after the dash)

[1] Publish unaltered --- 
[2] Publish with minor revisions --- 
[3] Publish with major revisions ---
[4] Reject: inappropriate material ---
...............submit to another conference/journal: 
[5] Reject: inadequate quality ---

JUSTIFICATION
-------------
(Please place an X after each appropriate dash, and add comments here or
at the end of the document.)

RELEVANCE TO MINITRACK THEME:
Relevance to Theme#1: Organizations: High ---
Relevance to Theme#1: Organizations: Moderate ---
Relevance to Theme#1: Organizations: Low ---
Relevance to Theme#1: Organizations: Not Applicable (N/A) ---

Relevance to Theme#2: Information Systems: High ---
Relevance to Theme#2: Information Systems: Moderate ---
Relevance to Theme#2: Information Systems: Low ---
Relevance to Theme#2: Information Systems: N/A ---

Relevance to Theme#3: Integrating Hypertext with IS: High ---
Relevance to Theme#3: Integrating Hypertext with IS: Moderate ---
Relevance to Theme#3: Integrating Hypertext with IS: Low ---
Relevance to Theme#3: Integrating Hypertext with IS: N/A ---

THE PAPER'S RESEARCH CONTRIBUTION: 
Theoretical Research Contribution: Significant ---
Theoretical Research Contribution: Moderate ---
Theoretical Research Contribution: Low/Unclear ---
Theoretical Research Contribution: N/A---

Quality of Experiments: Significant ---
Quality of Experiments: Moderate ---
Quality of Experiments: Low/Unclear ---
Quality of Experiments: N/A---

System Evaluation: Significant ---
System Evaluation: Moderate ---
System Evaluation: Low/Unclear ---
System Evaluation: N/A---

Overview of Hypermedia Systems or Research: Significant ---
Overview of Hypermedia Systems or Research: Moderate ---
Overview of Hypermedia Systems or Research: Low/Unclear ---
Overview of Hypermedia Systems or Research: N/A---

Quality of Prototype Implementation: Significant ---
Quality of Prototype Implementation: Moderate ---
Quality of Prototype Implementation: Low/Unclear ---
Quality of Prototype Implementation: N/A---

Importance to the IS Community: High ---
Importance to the IS Community: Moderate ---
Importance to the IS Community: Unclear ---

OTHER PAPER CHARACTERISTICS: 
Appropriate Conclusions: Outstanding ---
Appropriate Conclusions: Good ---
Appropriate Conclusions: Poor/Unclear ---

Originality: Outstanding ---
Originality: Good ---
Originality: Not much ---

Technically: Significant ---
Technically: OK ---
Technically: N/A ---
Technically: Not Sound --- 
Missing Technical Information: Yes (what?) ---

References: Too many ---
References: Too few ---
Key References Missing (which ones?) ---

Abstract: OK ---
Abstract: Doesn't bring out the main points of paper ---

Title: OK ---
Title: Misleading ---

Introduction: Outstanding ---
Introduction: OK ---
Introduction: Doesn't bring out the main points of paper ---

Needs Editing Review: No ---
Needs Editing Review: Yes ---

Length: Too Long ---
Length: OK ---
Length: Too Short ---

Organization: Good --- 
Organization: Unsalvageable --- 
Organization: Needs Improvement (how?) --- 

Clarity: Good --- 
Clarity: Unsalvageable --- 
Clarity: Needs Improvement (how?) --- 

Writing: Good --- 
Writing: Unsalvageable --- 
Writing: Needs Improvement (how?) --- 

Graphics (Diagrams, figures, tables, charts): Good --- 
Graphics: Inappropriate --- 
Graphics: Needs Improvement (how?) ---

____________________________________________________________________________
Comments to the Authors:






____________________________________________________________________________
Comments to the Editors:






____________________________________________________________________________

Please return to:  bieber@cis.njit.edu by August 15, 1994