HICSS-96 Minitrack on Hypermedia in Information Systems and Organizations REFEREE FORM Please e-mail to: by Tuesday August 22, 1995 =================================================================== Paper Number: XX Title: XXX Reviewer: XXXX =================================================================== Use the following scale for your ratings THROUGHOUT this form Low High N/A 1 2 3 4 5 =================================================================== MINITRACK THEME Organizations : _ Information Systems : _ Integrating Hypertext with IS : _ General Hypermedia Research : _ =================================================================== RESEARCH CONTRIBUTION: Theoretical Research Contribution : _ Comments: ___ Quality of Experiments : _ Comments: ___ System Evaluation : _ Comments: ___ Overview of Hypermedia Systems or Research: _ Comments: ___ Quality of Prototype Implementation : _ Comments: ___ OTHER RESEARCH CHARACTERISTICS: Appropriate Conclusions : _ Comments: ___ Originality : _ Comments: ___ Technically Sound : _ Comments: ___ Technical Information Missing (what?): ___ PAPER CONTENT: Title choice : _ Comments: ___ Abstract : _ Comments: ___ Introduction : _ Comments: ___ Appropriate Conclusions : _ Comments: ___ References : _ Comments: ___ Key References Missing (which ones?) ___ WRITING CHARACTERISTICS: Length : _ Comments: ___ Organization : _ Comments: ___ Clarity : _ Comments: ___ Graphics (figures, etc.) : _ Comments: ___ Needs English Editing (Y/N): _ Comments: ___ =================================================================== OVERALL RATINGS MINITRACK SUITABILITY: _ RESEARCH CONTRIBUTION: _ TECHNICAL CONTENT : _ ORIGINALITY : _ RELEVANCE : _ Indicate IS/MIS or CS Community: _ WRITING QUALITY : _ =================================================================== OVERALL RECOMMENDATION: accept (with minor or no revisions) [ ] accept with major revisions [ ] accept with major revisions only if there is space [ ] reject: inadequate quality [ ] reject: inappropriate material [ ] ........submit to another conference/journal: ___ =================================================================== Plentiful comments for author(s): =================================================================== EVALUATION INFORMATION *** Authors Will NOT See The Following Comments *** Please rate your interest and/or ability to review the paper: * very good [ ] * good [ ] * average [ ] * marginal [ ] * it was a mistake to send me this paper [ ] Comments for the Minitrack Coordinators: =================================================================== Please e-mail to: by Tuesday August 22, 1995