|
|
Project
Summary: New Columbia
OWNER/DEVELOPER
Housing Authority of Portland
ARCHITECT
Mithun/Robertson Merryman Barnes and others
PLANNING
Mithun
LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECT
Murase Associates
CONTRACTORS
Walsh Construction PROPERTY
MANAGEMENT
Housing Authority of Portland
FUNDERS: |
TYPE: |
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) |
HOPE VI $35 million seed grant |
DEVELOPMENT
TYPE:
Mixed-use, multi-family redevelopment.
RESIDENT
PROFILE:
230 townhomes at market rate; 620 operated by the Housing Authority of Portland for 2 income levels: 370 rental units for people at 0-30% area median income and 190 rental units for people at 30-60% area median income; also 60 rental units of housing for the elderly.
DENSITY: 10.4 units/acre
DEVELOPMENT
PROFILE
Type |
#/Units |
Size
(sf) |
Rent |
1 BR |
114 |
648-770 |
n/a |
2
BR |
177 |
810-1087 |
n/a |
3 BR |
128 |
1148-1245 |
n/a |
4 BR |
124 |
1490-1565 |
n/a |
5 BR |
15 |
1731 |
n/a |
6 BR |
2 |
n/a |
n/a |
Total: 852 total/620 affordable units including 60 units of housing for the elderly* |
*Elderly housing includes 15 studios, 30 1BR and 15 2BR
Laundry: community facilities in two mixed-use buildings
Courtyard/play: 8.5 acres overall; 3.8 in main park and 4.5 in pocket parks
Parking: 763 on-street (parallel parking in the public right-of-way); 620 off-street (1 per unit, served from alleyways)
Total site area:
82 acres |
CONSTRUCTION
TYPE
Wood frame, two and three stories.
DEVELOPMENT
COSTS:
Total
development costs: $35 million ($41,176/unit);
Completed in December 2006. |
|
|
New Columbia is an 852 unit, mixed-income townhouse development that focuses on four principles: |
- Replacing unattractive, impersonal, barracks-style buildings with townhouses, garden-style apartments and single-family dwellings that blend aesthetically into the environment;
|
- Reducing the concentration of poverty in the former Columbia Villa by building a neighborhood of varied types of housing, rented and owned, to attract economically diverse residents;
|
- Providing services to residents to increase their skills through education and training, leading to better employment while building assets and equity in the community;
|
- Establishing and maintaining high standards of personal and community responsibility through explicit lease requirements and home ownership.
|
The initial planning for New Columbia began
in July 2000, when HAP (Housing Authority of Portland)
and the resident association of the previous development (Columbia
Villa) teamed up to pursue a HOPE VI revitalization grant from
the Department of Housing and Urban Development. As planning
progressed, sustainability charrettes were held to establish
community metrics – from
overall goals to individual system choices. Each meeting was
four hours long and occurred monthly over the course of 10
months. From local students to nearby business owners, existing
residents to contractors, all were invited to share their perspectives.
The community's final master plan was developed through this
extensive process and included goals for safety and security,
economic diversity, accessibility and sustainable design.
New Columbia sits within a dense urban area. The site plan of the previous development turned inward, connecting with the orderly street grid surrounding it at only four points.
By 2000, the existing development was known for its deteriorating infrastructure, high maintenance costs, unclaimed exterior space and sterile architectural aesthetic. It was also known for its high crime rate. The redevelopment has not only revitalized the formerly ignored neighborhood, it has also become a destination for the surrounding community. The denser, pedestrian-friendly environment with pocket parks, common greens, accessible transit and a large central park draws visitors in and helps to re-knit the fabric of North Portland. Eight hundred fifty-two new housing units were built, approximately 620 of which are affordable. The housing design reflects local climate and building customs by drawing from regional Craftsman traditions. Porches with large-scale columns and a variety of gable ends and shed dormers give the townhome designs character and scale, with varied colors keeping the look diverse and appealing.
The New Columbia neighborhood exemplifies “Location
Efficient Design,” the goals of which are: to maximize
accessibility and affordability by linking housing with jobs
through good transit systems; to create good cycling and walking
conditions; and to conserve land by redeveloping underutilized
sites. New Columbia's use of these principles is evident throughout
the community. The neighborhood is close to several recreational
areas including parks and wildlife refuges, as well as popular
public transportation options for an easy commute to anywhere
in the metro area. The streets have been laid out on a grid pattern
that connects to the surrounding community, with pedestrian paths
bisecting the longer blocks. Pedestrians and cyclists were given
priority at New Columbia. Streets are narrow to slow traffic
and bring the community together, whether on foot or by bicycle.
Secure indoor bicycle storage is provided for residents. Car
parking is located in alleys behind the housing. Four one-quarter
acre parks and a centralized four acre city park provide outdoor
space close to home. The neighborhood city park is the heart
of the community and includes public pools, parks and
wildlife refuges. In addition, a small neighborhood commercial
zone is planned, which will house community services and small,
locally-owned businesses.
A hierarchy of open spaces encourages residents to get outside, from front yards and bioswales within streetscapes to parks of varying sizes. The housing authority and architect worked to respect the site’s ecological significance and its place within the fabric of the city. The site’s natural features include wetlands and stately trees, both vital habitats that mandate preservation and protection, and are of great value to residents. Most of the site’s 430 trees were planted in 1942 when the previous development was built to house World War II shipyard workers. In New Columbia, over half of these trees were preserved through careful planning and good design. Thirty-nine percent of the total caliper inches (a measurement of the width of the trunk) were saved out of the 47% originally proposed; those taken down were done so out of sheer necessity. Trees retained from the original development provide shade to the new homes on the site and create greenways that encourage outdoor activity. Additionally, root balls of large trees that were removed were donated to local streambed restoration projects. Smaller caliper trees were moved from building sites and roadways to the main park in the neighborhood. Open spaces were designed around the largest, most beautiful existing trees, including the largest tree on site – a silver maple with a sixty-four inch diameter.
Building systems and materials were chosen for
their sustainable features, with extensive attention paid to
energy use and savings. In two units, solar panels assist in
heating and electrical needs. Solar panels are mounted on the
south-facing roofs of the townhouses and use the sun to pre-heat
water before it goes to the hot water heater and is distributed
to the apartments. The performance of the panels is being monitored
for future projects. Hydronic space heaters were installed
to minimize indoor air quality issues sometimes associated with
forced air systems. The plumbing systems out-perform Oregon’s
water code by 30%. Each unit has a water submeter that allows residents
to track their own conservation efforts. A natural drainage system,
which includes permeable pavement, cleans, cools and filters stormwater.
Energy Star appliances and lighting are used throughout to produce
an estimated savings of about $105 per household. Units are equipped
with washer and dryer hook up, and residents have been offered
a $50 in-kind contribution from the Energy Trust of Oregon and
other state tax credits to purchase Energy Star clothes washers.
With a stormwater management system that employs Low Impact Development (LID) strategies using topography, vegetation and soil features to naturally infiltrate rain water into the groundwater aquifer where it falls, Portland’s Bureau of Environmental Services calls New Columbia “the ultimate green streets development.” The development includes 101 pocket swales, 31 flow-through planter boxes and 40 public infiltration dry wells. New Columbia has 80% less underground stormwater piping than a comparable traditional development, and retains 98% of the stormwater that falls on public and private property on site. According to the Housing Authority of Portland, stormwater from public streets is treated in biofiltration areas (swales and planter boxes) located within the public rights-of-way. Biofiltration areas are designed to allow run-off to filter through the planter soils and then infiltrate into native soils. Small storm events are completely infilitrated by the swales and planter boxes while large storm events cause the swales and planter boxes to overflow into 30-foot deep drywells located below the streets. (New Columbia factsheets - see below for more information).
Construction practices minimized the risks of mold and mildew. Front and rear doors are protected by porches and deep overhangs, eliminating the introduction of wind-driven rain. At all exterior walls, joints between sheets of sheathing (on the exterior) and drywall (on the interior) are sealed with draft sealants. Quiet mechanical fans installed in all kitchens, bathrooms, and utility rooms are vented to the outside and run at low speed around the clock to reduce the risk of mold and to ensure indoor chemicals and pollutants are quickly evacuated. Fresh make-up air is brought into units through operable window vents. In addition, blower door tests were performed on a random sample of units to measure building envelope air leakage and allow the contractor to tighten up the buildings.
Renewable resources and recycling were thoroughly considered in the design and construction processes. Rapidly renewable and reclaimed wood products were used whenever possible. More than 35,000 board feet of FSC certified sustainable lumber were used, as well as advanced framing techniques to reduce the amount of framing lumber needed. Floor joists, beams and headers are all engineered lumber. The buildings are clad in recycled content fiber-cement siding, which looks like traditional wood siding but is non-combustible and has an expected lifespan of fifty years. High recycled fiber content batt insulation and drywall made of 100% synthetic gypsum with a recycled paper face were used as well. Locally manufactured products at New Columbia include windows, millwork and metal products made in Western Oregon and Washington.
Air quality was of utmost importance to the project team, which was sensitive to studies showing asthma’s disproportionate impact upon the poor. The homes have hard surface flooring, VOC-free paints, low-VOC cabinetry, adhesives, finishes and sealants, air-tight drywall construction with no- or low-VOC joint compound and an improved ventilation system. The homes were also commissioned to ensure that they are functioning as designed. Carpeting is a 100% nylon fiber that contains no VOCs and is installed over a high quality VOC-free pad. Vinyl flooring is a high quality, durable and inflexible low-VOC material. Even the project’s contractors were barred from smoking when on site. Prior to occupancy, the buildings were flushed with outdoor air to remove residual contaminants. Notably, all of the homes meet the local Built Green three star standard.
The contractors of New Columbia minimized waste for all phases of construction, including demolition. A goal of 80% total waste reuse and recycling by weight was set. On-site storage for all materials to be recycled was provided including wood, drywall, metal, plastic, glass, cardboard and organic debris. The Housing Authority of Portland notes that demolition contractors salvaged and recycled 82% of the building materials on site and diverted more than 28,500 tons of “waste” from the landfill (New Columbia factsheets). All of the concrete and asphalt rubble generated by the demolition of Columbia Villa was ground into gravel-sized pieces and reused on site as road base and structural fill around building foundations. Twenty-three of Columbia Villa’s duplex buildings were purchased by local house moving companies and removed from the site intact. The Rebuilding Center, a local salvage company, deconstructed two four-unit buildings and salvaged every component of the buildings for resale, with the exception of plaster and insulation. Thirty-two hundred tons of wood debris were ground into chips, reused on site for erosion control or sold to farmers and ranchers as bedding for animal pens. A storage building was purchased and disassembled on site by a landscape contractor and reassembled in Vancouver, Washington. Salvaged materials from Columbia Villa have been reused locally and all over the world. Heavy timbers were re-sawn for use as architectural finish material in Japan. A Tongan man living in Portland purchased enough lumber, roofing, windows, appliances and plumbing fixtures from the project to build three houses for his family in Tonga. Twelve hundred square feet of roofing material was donated to re-roof an elderly woman’s home in Salem. Enough windows and siding were donated to the local Amity school district to refurbish an entire school and gymnasium. None of the windows that had been replaced at Columbia Villa in the 1990s were discarded; they were sold to other housing developers, neighboring homeowners, and the Habitat for Humanity ReStore and the Rebuilding Center. Salvaged building materials, including windows, metal roofing, siding, structural timber, plywood, cabinetry, doors, door hardware, appliances, furnaces, water heaters, toilets, sinks, and bath tubs, were returned to the Housing Authority of Portland for use at other public and affordable housing sites or purchased by contractors and private parties.
Two buildings at New Columbia (one designed by Mithun) are the first HOPE VI grant recipients also to receive LEED certification: Trenton North and Trenton South. Both are mixed-use buildings consisting of a combined 75 units of rental housing. Housing Authority of Portland’s (HAP) leasing office as well as a community center are located in Trenton North. A coffee shop, small grocer and a community program through Portland Community College are located on the first floor of Trenton South.
New Columbia joins New Urbanist concepts with fundamental, integrated green guidelines creating a new model for sustainability: a vibrant, walkable, mixed-income community that respects human and ecological needs and is both livable and sustainable.
Lessons Learned from the Architect
-
Because of budget and time constraints, certain items could only be demonstrated, such as the solar hot water heater, which was included in only a couple of units. Other systems were demonstrated but could not be included at all. Some units were part of the Building America project and had great modelling numbers - 70-75% over Oregon energy standards and an EPA Energy Star rating of 92 - but cost $1000 more than units without similar energy saving features and were not used.
-
Skinny streets throughout the site were
originally proposed but only one was included as a test case
because of ongoing concerns with the city.
Jury Comments
- Traditional but with thoughtful details. One of the better energy efficient/green HOPE VI projects.
- This is well done, especially for this scale.
- Fairly holistic approach, and a design that doesn’t "look" like a specific type.
Much of this information adapted from the Housing Authority of Portland's "New Columbia Factsheets and Background Information."
AIA Green Housing Guidelines
|
New Columbia
|
1
|
Community Context |
Infill/ brownfield/adaptive re-use/high density |
New Columbia replaced Columbia Villa, a distressed public housing project built over 60 years ago to house World War II shipyard workers. It was targeted for redevelopment by the federal HOPE VI grant program.
|
Locate near public transportation |
Access to Interstate Max Light Rail is nearby for transportation to anywhere in the metro area. A Tri-Met bus line runs through the site.
|
2 |
Site Design |
Pedestrian/bicycle friendly |
The streets have been laid out in a grid pattern that connects to the surrounding community, with pedestrian paths bisecting the longer blocks. Streets are narrow to slow traffic. |
3 |
Building Design |
Daylighting |
Large glazing was used to maximize daylighting in town houses. In the mixed use building, which faces the main street, large glazing and canopies for shading have been used. |
4
|
Water Conservation and Management |
Stormwater Management |
A natural drainage system – which includes permeable pavement – cleans, cools and filters stormwater. Stormwater from public streets is treated in biofiltration areas (swales and planter boxes) located within public rights-of-way. Biofiltration areas are designed to allow run-off to filter through the planter soils and then infiltrate into native soils. Small storm events are completely infiltrated by the swales and planter boxes while large storm events cause the swales and planter boxes to overflow into 30-foot deep drywells located below the streets.
|
Water Saving Appliances |
Plumbing systems out-perform Oregon’s water code by 30%.
|
5
|
Energy Efficiency |
Energy Efficiency Heating and Cooling |
Solar panels assist in heating needs.
|
Energy Star Appliances/Lighting |
Energy Star appliances and lighting have been used.
|
7 |
Recycling |
Recycled Content Materials or Recycling On Site |
Rapidly renewable and reclaimed wood products were used whenever possible; also recycled content fiber-cement siding, high recycled fiber content batt insulation, LEED-certified drywall made of 100% synthetic gypsum with a recycled paper face. 80% of deconstructed materials from the previous development were reused or recycled.
|
8 |
IEQ |
Limit Emissions/moisture/sound/allergens |
VOC-free paints, low-VOC cabinetry, adhesives, finishes and sealants; air-tight drywall construction with no- or low- VOC joint compound and texture.Carpeting is a 100% nylon fiber that contains no VOCs and is installed over a high quality VOC-free pad. Vinyl flooring is high quality, durable and inflexible low-VOC material. Also included were an improved ventilation system and commissioning. Thorough ventilation with industrial fans prior to occupancy removed residual contaminants.
|
|